I'm going to take back what I said about the Chubby Sticks by Clinique. Ignoring the fact that it has a terrible name, and ignoring the fact that I still am not in love- I found mine and actually have been using it like a chap stick. It is semi moisturizing and the color is natural, although not long lasting. I change my review and give it 3/5 lippies. It still doesn't last and it is not as moisturizing as lip balm. Give me lip balm and give me lipstick!